MaxArc Global Health Impact Platform

Risk, Incident, Investigation & Case Governance

FOR GLOBAL FUND / CCM / AUTHORIZED PARTNER REVIEW ONLY
Risk · Incident · Investigation · Corrective action · Escalation · Case governance · Immutable audit · Demonstration only

Cross-module risk, incident, investigation, and case governance with human approval.

A synthetic governance demonstration — not a law-enforcement system, whistleblower intake platform, legal case-management system, autonomous investigation service, fraud adjudication engine, regulatory reporting system, or replacement for authorized investigative authorities. A signal is not a finding, an anomaly is not proof, an allegation is not a determination, and a risk score is not a legal conclusion. Opening a case does not establish guilt, diversion, fraud, misconduct, negligence, or liability. Source-module records remain authoritative; cases reference but never silently modify them. No live integration, real database mutation, autonomous investigation, real evidence upload, real file delivery, or punitive automation is implemented. AI is assistive only and never substantiates allegations, approves findings, closes or reopens cases, notifies external parties, or bypasses controls.

You are viewing the Risk, Incident & Case Governance Dashboard — Synthetic non-identifiable demonstration data
Case-governance posture: A signal is not a finding, an anomaly is not proof, an allegation is not a determination, and a risk score is not a legal conclusion. Opening a case does not establish guilt, diversion, fraud, misconduct, negligence, or liability. Source-module records remain authoritative; cases may reference source records but never silently modify them. Every case identifies its category, source module, owner, assigned roles, status, severity, confidentiality, evidence, timeline, review status, and audit reference. Every material decision identifies the decision-maker, role, reason, evidence, timestamp, and audit reference.
Investigation posture: Investigations are structured, attributable, and evidence-bounded. The investigator cannot provide sole final approval where independent review is required. The case creator cannot independently approve closure. The source-record owner cannot independently resolve a disputed case where independent review is required. An AI-generated hypothesis cannot become a finding without human evidence review. Contradictory evidence and investigation limitations remain visible. A finding must identify supporting and conflicting evidence, and no conclusion may exceed the available evidence.
Corrective-action posture: Action completion is not the same as effectiveness verification. Overdue and failed or ineffective actions remain visible. Action owners cannot independently verify high-risk actions where second review is required. Case closure requires the required corrective actions and closure criteria. Ineffective remediation may trigger case reopening. Remediation does not erase the original incident or investigation record.
Immutable audit posture: Audit events are append-only in this demonstration model. Historical states remain visible. Corrections, finding reversals, and reopen events require new linked events. Deletion is not an allowed case-management control. Source-module audit records remain authoritative. This task does not implement a production cryptographic evidence or audit ledger.
Total risks 8

Prioritization only

Open risks 5

Unmitigated

Total incidents 14

Cross-module

Open incidents 10

Not yet contained

Active investigations 14

In progress

Open cases 14

Not closed

High-severity cases 8

Priority

Critical cases 1

Highest priority

Blocked cases 3

Insufficient evidence / SoD

Escalated cases 7

Independent review

Awaiting second review 10

High-risk

Cases missing evidence 3

Remain visible

Cases conflicting evidence 1

Both retained

Overdue investigations 14

Past due date

Overdue corrective actions 12

Remain visible

Reopened cases 2

Auditable

Appeals / reconsiderations 2

Remain visible

Containment in progress 1

Active

Corrective in progress 6

Active

Preventive in progress 5

Active

Remediation completion 29%

Completion ≠ effectiveness

Ineffective actions 1

Remain visible

Cross-module incidents 1

Span modules

SoD rules 18

Enforced

AI signals 13

Human review required

Audit events 15

Append-only

Risks (prioritization only)

Risk scores support prioritization only. Low confidence remains visible; a high score does not establish wrongdoing. Stale assessments require re-review and residual risk remains visible after mitigation.

RiskDescriptionScore / severityStatus
RISK-001
fund-accountability · financial
Risk of undocumented expenditure variance across grant disbursements. score 72 high
likelihood medium · impact high · confidence medium
in-progress
residual medium · review 2025-09-01 · audit AUD-001
RISK-002
stockpile-logistics · supply-chain
Risk of commodity diversion between dispatch and receipt. score 78 high
likelihood medium · impact high · confidence medium
open
residual high · review 2025-08-15 · audit AUD-002
RISK-003
lab-operations · clinical-quality
Risk of laboratory quality-control failure affecting result reliability. score 58 medium
likelihood low · impact high · confidence high
in-progress
residual low · review 2025-09-10 · audit AUD-004
RISK-004
restricted-patient-locator · privacy
Risk of unauthorized restricted-locator access. score 70 high
likelihood low · impact high · confidence medium
open
residual medium · review 2025-08-20 · audit AUD-007
RISK-005
asset-management · operational
Risk of asset loss or unauthorized transfer. score 55 medium
likelihood medium · impact medium · confidence medium
in-progress
residual medium · review 2025-09-05 · audit AUD-008
RISK-006
program-performance · information-integrity
Risk of program-result integrity concerns from implausible reporting. score 74 high
likelihood medium · impact high · confidence medium
open
residual high · review 2025-08-25 · audit AUD-009
RISK-007
identity-access-governance · governance
Risk of identity-governance violations from expired-but-active access. score 76 high
likelihood medium · impact high · confidence medium
open
residual high · review 2025-09-15 · audit AUD-013
RISK-008
fund-accountability · financial
Legacy risk assessment retained for prioritization history; assessment is stale. score 50 medium
likelihood medium · impact medium · confidence low · stale
requires-re-review
residual medium · review 2024-11-01 · audit AUD-018

Incidents (an incident is not a finding)

Each incident records category, detection, source module, affected scope, severity, containment, evidence, impact, and audit reference across all covered modules.

IncidentCategorySeverity / containmentImpact assessment
INC-001
suspected-commodity-diversion
suspected-diversion
fund-accountability · grant-disbursement
high in-progress Potential undocumented disbursement variance under review; not established as diversion.
case CASE-001 · audit AUD-001
INC-002
warehouse-dispatch-receipt-discrepancy
dispatch-receipt-discrepancy
stockpile-logistics · warehouse-to-facility
high in-progress Dispatch of 5,000 units with receipt confirmation missing; discrepancy under review.
case CASE-002 · audit AUD-002
INC-003
unexplained-stock-loss
stock-loss
stockpile-logistics · facility-store
medium contained Recorded balance exceeds movement-derived balance by 25 units; cause unresolved.
case CASE-003 · audit AUD-003
INC-004
lab-qc-failure
lab-qc-failure
lab-operations · lab-batch
medium contained Quality-control run outside control limits; affected batch quarantined pending re-run.
case CASE-004 · audit AUD-004
INC-005
delayed-misrouted-lab-result
result-routing
lab-operations · restricted-result
high in-progress Restricted result not routed to clinician; potential care delay under review.
case CASE-005 · audit AUD-005
INC-006
patient-continuity-interruption
continuity-interruption
patient-continuity · referral-transfer-followup
medium in-progress Follow-up record missing for a completed transfer; continuity interruption under review.
case CASE-005B · audit AUD-006
INC-007
restricted-locator-access-concern
restricted-access-concern
restricted-patient-locator · restricted-records
high contained Access concern raised on a restricted-locator request; no restricted details disclosed.
case CASE-006 · audit AUD-007
INC-008
asset-loss-unauthorized-transfer
asset-loss
asset-management · facility-asset
medium in-progress Asset register active but custody unverified; possible unauthorized transfer under review.
case CASE-007 · audit AUD-008
INC-009
program-result-integrity-concern
program-result-integrity
program-performance · program-reporting
high in-progress Reported result implausibly exceeds target; integrity concern under review, not a finding.
case CASE-008 · audit AUD-009
INC-010
unusual-ai-pattern
ai-pattern
ai-intelligence · cross-module
medium monitoring AI clustered a possible-duplicate-disbursement pattern; an anomaly is not a finding.
case CASE-009 · audit AUD-010
INC-011
rollout-control-failure
rollout-control-failure
country-rollout · facility-readiness
medium in-progress Readiness claimed while a dependency remains incomplete; rollout control failure under review.
case CASE-010 · audit AUD-011
INC-012
unauthorized-reviewroom-packet-access
unauthorized-access-attempt
authorized-review-room · review-package
high contained Unauthorized review-room / packet access attempt blocked; no restricted content disclosed.
case CASE-012 · audit AUD-012
INC-013
identity-governance-violation
identity-violation
identity-access-governance · privileged-access
high in-progress Access decision approved but authorization expired while still represented as active.
case CASE-011 · audit AUD-013
INC-014
data-quality-reconciliation-conflict
reconciliation-conflict
data-quality-reconciliation · cross-module-claim
high in-progress Reconciliation conflict between a packet claim and verified capability state; both remain visible.
case CASE-013 · audit AUD-014

Cases (allegation is not a determination)

Every case identifies category, source module, owner, assigned roles, status, severity, confidentiality, evidence, timeline, review status, and audit reference. Unresolved cases are never represented as closed. Missing and conflicting evidence remain visible.

CaseCategory / scopeStatusEvidence / posture
CASE-001
fund-accountability · FUND-DISB-1187
financial-integrity
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-03
high open SoD compliant 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
audit AUD-001
CASE-002
stockpile-logistics · DISP-7781
commodity-integrity
CN-A · FAC-B1 · PRG-MAL · owner ACT-03
critical blocked SoD violation 2nd review missing evidence allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-008 · audit AUD-002
CASE-003
stockpile-logistics · STOCK-BAL-A1-0925
commodity-integrity
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-TB · owner ACT-08
medium open SoD compliant allegation ≠ finding
audit AUD-003
CASE-004
lab-operations · LAB-BATCH-3390
laboratory-quality
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-03
medium closed SoD compliant allegation ≠ finding
audit AUD-004
CASE-005
lab-operations · RES-55121
laboratory-quality
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-03
high blocked SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-009 · audit AUD-005
CASE-005B
patient-continuity · REF-2201
patient-safety-continuity
CN-A · FAC-A2 · PRG-TB · owner ACT-03
medium open SoD compliant missing evidence allegation ≠ finding
audit AUD-006
CASE-006
restricted-patient-locator · LOC-REQ-770
privacy-access
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-03
high open SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-010 · audit AUD-007
CASE-007
asset-management · ASSET-9032
asset-accountability
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-MAL · owner ACT-08
medium reopened SoD violation allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-011 · audit AUD-008
CASE-008
program-performance · PRG-RES-6612
program-integrity
CN-A · FAC-A2 · PRG-TB · owner ACT-03
high escalated SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-012 · audit AUD-009
CASE-009
ai-intelligence · AIC-2050
ai-signal-review
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-04
medium open SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-013 · audit AUD-010
CASE-010
country-rollout · RDY-CLAIM-330
rollout-control
CN-B · FAC-B1 · PRG-MAL · owner ACT-02
medium open SoD violation missing evidence allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-014 · audit AUD-011
CASE-011
identity-access-governance · IAG-DEC-508
identity-governance
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-10
high escalated SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-016 · audit AUD-013
CASE-012
executive-review-packet · PKT-ACCESS-14
review-access-control
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-07
high open SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-015 · audit AUD-012
CASE-013
data-quality-reconciliation · DQC-014
data-quality-integrity
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-01
high blocked SoD violation 2nd review conflicting evidence allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-017 · audit AUD-014
CASE-014
authorized-review-room · RVR-PKG-22
review-access-control
CN-A · FAC-A1 · PRG-HIV · owner ACT-07
high open SoD violation 2nd review allegation ≠ finding
rule SOD-015 · audit AUD-012

Investigations

The investigator cannot provide sole final approval where independent review is required; contradictory evidence and limitations remain visible; no conclusion may exceed available evidence.

InvestigationScopeStatus / rolesLimitations
INV-001
case CASE-001
Assess whether the disbursement-expenditure variance reflects timing or unrecorded expenditure. in-progress 2nd review SoD compliant
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-04-08
Expenditure evidence partially unverified.
INV-002
case CASE-002
Determine cause of the dispatch/receipt discrepancy with missing receipt confirmation. overdue 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-06-20
Receipt confirmation missing; conclusion cannot exceed evidence.
INV-003
case CASE-003
Investigate the 25-unit stock balance/movement divergence. in-progress SoD compliant
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-08-03
Physical recount pending.
INV-004
case CASE-004
Investigate the laboratory quality-control failure and confirm remediation. completed SoD compliant
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-05-27
None material.
INV-005
case CASE-005
Investigate the unrouted restricted laboratory result. overdue 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-06-15
Restricted case; minimum-necessary access.
INV-006
case CASE-005B
Investigate the missing follow-up record for a completed transfer. in-progress SoD compliant
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-06-21
Follow-up evidence missing.
INV-007
case CASE-006
Investigate the restricted-locator access concern. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-06-03
Restricted case; denied access does not confirm details.
INV-008
case CASE-007
Investigate the asset custody discrepancy and prior ineffective remediation. in-progress SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-09-02
Custody unverified.
INV-009
case CASE-008
Investigate the implausible program result. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-07-22
Source document unverified.
INV-010
case CASE-009
Review the AI-clustered duplicate-disbursement pattern against source evidence. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-07-02
AI hypothesis cannot become a finding without human evidence review.
INV-011
case CASE-010
Investigate the rollout control failure (readiness vs dependency). in-progress SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-10-02
Dependency evidence missing.
INV-012
case CASE-011
Investigate the expired-but-active privileged access. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-09-16
Approver cannot resolve their own discrepancy.
INV-013
case CASE-012
Investigate the unauthorized packet-access attempt. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-08-11
Restricted case.
INV-014
case CASE-013
Investigate the reconciliation conflict between a packet claim and verified capability state. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-08-05
Conflicting verified evidence; conclusion cannot exceed evidence.
INV-015
case CASE-014
Investigate an authorized review-room access-attribution concern for a shared evidence package. in-progress 2nd review SoD violation
investigator investigator · independent independent-reviewer · due 2025-08-13
Restricted case; minimum-necessary access.

Finding states (distinct & evidence-bounded)

  • Unreviewed — No human evidence review has occurred.
  • Unsubstantiated — Reviewed; evidence does not support the allegation.
  • Inconclusive — Evidence neither supports nor refutes the allegation.
  • Partially substantiated — Some, not all, elements are supported by evidence.
  • Substantiated — Evidence supports the allegation within platform scope; not a legal determination.
  • Disproven — Evidence refutes the allegation.
  • Blocked (insufficient evidence) — A finding is blocked because required evidence is missing or conflicting.

Dispositions (distinct from findings & remediation)

  • DISP-001 — case CASE-001 monitoring
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-001
  • DISP-002 — case CASE-002 referral-blocked
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-002
  • DISP-003 — case CASE-003 control-remediation
    decided by independent-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-003
  • DISP-004 — case CASE-004 closed-after-approval
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-004
  • DISP-005 — case CASE-005 management-review
    decided by independent-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-005
  • DISP-006 — case CASE-005B no-further-action
    decided by case-owner · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-006
  • DISP-007 — case CASE-006 compliance-review
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-007
  • DISP-008 — case CASE-007 case-reopened
    decided by independent-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-008
  • DISP-009 — case CASE-008 referral-eligible
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-009
  • DISP-010 — case CASE-009 monitoring
    decided by independent-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-010
  • DISP-011 — case CASE-010 control-remediation
    decided by independent-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-011
  • DISP-012 — case CASE-011 management-review
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-013
  • DISP-013 — case CASE-012 closure-pending
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-012
  • DISP-014 — case CASE-013 compliance-review
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-014
  • DISP-015 — case CASE-014 management-review
    decided by compliance-reviewer · distinct from finding & remediation · audit AUD-012

Findings

Each finding identifies the allegation or question reviewed, its evidence-bounded state, confidence, and supporting, conflicting, and missing evidence. This platform does not represent criminal guilt, civil liability, disciplinary guilt, regulatory violation, or a formal fraud determination; such authority is outside the platform.

FindingAllegation / questionStateEvidence
FND-001
case CASE-001
Does the disbursement variance reflect unrecorded expenditure? inconclusive
confidence medium · approval pending
support: EVD-001 · conflict: — · missing: verified-expenditure-report
FND-002
case CASE-002
Was the dispatch/receipt gap caused by diversion? blocked-insufficient-evidence
confidence low · approval blocked
support: — · conflict: — · missing: receipt-confirmation
FND-003
case CASE-003
Is the stock divergence a counting error? partially-substantiated
confidence medium · approval pending
support: EVD-003 · conflict: — · missing: physical-recount
FND-004
case CASE-004
Was the QC failure caused by a reagent lot issue and remediated? substantiated
confidence high · approval approved
support: EVD-004 · conflict: — · missing: —
FND-005
case CASE-005
Why was the restricted result not routed? blocked-insufficient-evidence
confidence low · approval blocked
support: EVD-005 · conflict: EVD-017 · missing: verified-routing-record
FND-006
case CASE-005B
Was follow-up performed but unrecorded? unreviewed
confidence low · approval pending
support: — · conflict: — · missing: follow-up-record
FND-007
case CASE-006
Was the restricted-locator access appropriately authorized? inconclusive
confidence medium · approval pending
support: EVD-007 · conflict: — · missing: —
FND-008
case CASE-007
Was the asset transferred without authorization? unsubstantiated
confidence medium · approval reopened
support: EVD-008, EVD-016 · conflict: — · missing: —
FND-009
case CASE-008
Does the implausible result reflect fabrication? blocked-insufficient-evidence
confidence low · approval blocked
support: EVD-009 · conflict: — · missing: verified-source-document
FND-010
case CASE-009
Is the AI-clustered pattern a true duplicate? inconclusive
confidence low · approval pending
support: EVD-010 · conflict: — · missing: verified-signal-source
FND-011
case CASE-010
Was rollout readiness claimed prematurely? partially-substantiated
confidence medium · approval pending
support: — · conflict: — · missing: dependency-status-record
FND-012
case CASE-011
Why did expired access remain active? partially-substantiated
confidence medium · approval pending
support: EVD-013 · conflict: — · missing: —
FND-013
case CASE-012
Was the packet-access attempt deliberate? disproven
confidence medium · approval pending
support: EVD-012 · conflict: — · missing: —
FND-014
case CASE-013
Did the packet claim overstate the capability? blocked-insufficient-evidence
confidence low · approval blocked
support: EVD-014 · conflict: EVD-015 · missing: —
FND-015
case CASE-014
Was the authorized review-room access correctly attributed? inconclusive
confidence low · approval pending
support: EVD-012 · conflict: — · missing: EVD-MISSING-ATTRIB

Containment, corrective, preventive, recovery & effectiveness actions

Action completion is not effectiveness verification. Overdue and ineffective actions remain visible. Action owners cannot independently verify high-risk effectiveness where second review is required; ineffective remediation can trigger reopening; remediation does not erase incident or investigation history.

ActionTypeStatus / verificationEffectiveness
ACT-CN-001
case CASE-002
containment
Hold further dispatches on the affected route pending reconciliation.
in-progress
verify not-verified · 2nd review
pending
review 2025-07-01 · reopen: recurrence of discrepancy
ACT-CN-002
case CASE-005
containment
Quarantine the unrouted restricted result pending independent release review.
completed
verify verified · 2nd review
effective
review 2025-06-01 · reopen: further routing failure
ACT-CN-003
case CASE-012
access-restriction
Restrict packet access pending investigation.
completed
verify verified
effective
review 2025-08-01 · reopen: further unauthorized attempt
ACT-CA-001
case CASE-001
corrective
Obtain and verify the outstanding expenditure report.
in-progress
verify not-verified · 2nd review
pending
review 2025-05-01 · reopen: unresolved variance
ACT-CA-002
case CASE-003
inventory-recount
Perform an independent physical stock recount.
overdue overdue
verify not-verified
pending
review 2025-08-01 · reopen: divergence persists
ACT-CA-003
case CASE-007
corrective
Re-verify asset custody with independent confirmation.
completed
verify not-verified · 2nd review
ineffective
review 2025-08-18 · reopen: custody still unverified
ACT-CA-004
case CASE-008
reconciliation-rerun
Re-run numerator/denominator reconciliation with independent review.
in-progress
verify not-verified · 2nd review
pending
review 2025-08-15 · reopen: implausibility persists
ACT-CA-005
case CASE-011
access-restriction
Deactivate expired-but-active access pending review.
completed
verify verified · 2nd review
effective
review 2025-09-10 · reopen: reactivation without approval
ACT-CA-006
case CASE-013
evidence-re-verification
Independently re-verify conflicting capability evidence.
in-progress
verify not-verified · 2nd review
pending
review 2025-08-20 · reopen: conflict unresolved
ACT-CA-007
case CASE-004
independent-review
Independent review of QC remediation effectiveness.
completed
verify verified
effective
review 2025-05-20 · reopen: QC failure recurs
ACT-CA-008
case CASE-002
control-redesign
Redesign dispatch/receipt confirmation control.
in-progress
verify not-verified · 2nd review
pending
review 2025-08-30 · reopen: recurrence
ACT-PA-001
case CASE-001
preventive
Introduce a periodic disbursement-expenditure reconciliation check.
in-progress
verify not-verified
pending
review 2025-09-30 · reopen: variance recurs
ACT-PA-002
case CASE-005
training
Deliver restricted-result routing training (synthetic).
in-progress
verify not-verified
pending
review 2025-08-15 · reopen: routing failure recurs
ACT-PA-003
case CASE-010
policy-update
Update rollout-readiness policy to require dependency evidence.
in-progress
verify not-verified
pending
review 2025-11-15 · reopen: premature readiness recurs
ACT-RC-001
case CASE-003
recovery
Recover and reconcile any misplaced stock after recount.
in-progress
verify not-verified
pending
review 2025-08-20 · reopen: stock not recovered
ACT-MN-001
case CASE-009
monitoring
Monitor the AI-flagged pattern for recurrence pending human review.
in-progress
verify not-verified
pending
review 2025-08-02 · reopen: pattern recurs
ACT-COR-001
case CASE-014
correction
Request a documented correction of the review-room access-attribution record (source record remains authoritative; no silent modification).
in-progress
verify not-verified · 2nd review
pending
review 2025-09-01 · reopen: attribution remains unresolved

Separation-of-duties rules

Violations remain blocked or pending, identify the violated rule, require reassignment, independent review, or second review, remain auditable, and are never silently overridden.

RuleEnforcementOverride / audit
Signal creator cannot independently approve a final finding.
SOD-001 · signal-creator-cannot-approve-finding
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-001
Incident reporter cannot independently close the case.
SOD-002 · incident-reporter-cannot-close-case
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-002
Case creator cannot independently approve closure.
SOD-003 · case-creator-cannot-approve-closure
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-012
Investigator cannot independently provide final approval where independent review is required.
SOD-004 · investigator-cannot-final-approve
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-001
Evidence capturer cannot independently verify high-risk evidence.
SOD-005 · capturer-cannot-verify-high-risk-evidence
pending never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. EVD-008
Source-data owner cannot independently resolve a disputed finding.
SOD-006 · owner-cannot-resolve-disputed-finding
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-013
Fund investigator cannot independently authorize financial disposition.
SOD-007 · fund-investigator-cannot-authorize-financial-disposition
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-001
Warehouse dispatcher cannot independently resolve their own discrepancy case.
SOD-008 · dispatcher-cannot-resolve-own-discrepancy
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-002
Laboratory result preparer cannot independently close a result-integrity investigation.
SOD-009 · lab-preparer-cannot-close-result-integrity
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-005
Restricted-locator requestor cannot independently close an access concern.
SOD-010 · locator-requestor-cannot-close-access-concern
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-006
Asset custodian cannot independently close an asset-loss case.
SOD-011 · asset-custodian-cannot-close-asset-loss
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-007
Program-result submitter cannot independently close a result-integrity case.
SOD-012 · program-submitter-cannot-close-result-integrity
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-008
AI case generator cannot independently substantiate or close a case.
SOD-013 · ai-generator-cannot-substantiate-or-close
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-009
Rollout assessor cannot independently authorize closure of a rollout-control failure.
SOD-014 · rollout-assessor-cannot-authorize-closure
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-010
Packet author cannot independently resolve an unsupported-claim case.
SOD-015 · packet-author-cannot-resolve-unsupported-claim
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-012
Identity approver cannot independently close an access case involving their own decision.
SOD-016 · identity-approver-cannot-close-own-access-case
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-011
Correction requestor cannot independently close a linked reconciliation incident.
SOD-017 · correction-requestor-cannot-close-reconciliation-incident
blocked never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. CASE-013
Corrective-action owner cannot independently verify high-risk remediation effectiveness.
SOD-018 · corrective-action-owner-cannot-verify-high-risk-remediation
pending never silently overridden
auditable · e.g. ACT-CA-003

Escalations

  • ESC-001 — case CASE-002 open
    Missing receipt with dispatcher self-reconciliation attempt. · to independent-reviewer
  • ESC-002 — case CASE-005 open
    Restricted result unrouted; preparer self-closure attempt. · to independent-reviewer
  • ESC-003 — case CASE-008 open
    Implausible program result with submitter self-closure attempt. · to compliance-reviewer
  • ESC-004 — case CASE-010 open
    Unsupported readiness claim. · to independent-reviewer
  • ESC-005 — case CASE-011 open
    Expired access represented as active; approver conflict of interest. · to independent-reviewer
  • ESC-006 — case CASE-013 open
    Reconciliation conflict with conflicting verified evidence. · to compliance-reviewer

Closure reviews (criteria + human approval)

  • CLR-001 — case CASE-004 criteria met closed-after-approval
    approval approved · criteria: required corrective actions completed; effectiveness verified independently; no unresolved questions
  • CLR-002 — case CASE-012 criteria not met closure-pending
    approval pending · criteria: access restriction confirmed; no restricted content disclosed; second review complete
  • CLR-003 — case CASE-002 criteria not met closure-pending
    approval blocked · criteria: receipt evidence obtained; discrepancy reconciled; independent review complete

Reopen events (auditable)

  • REO-001 — case CASE-007
    Corrective action completed but effectiveness verification failed; remediation ineffective. · CASE-007-S1 → CASE-007-S2 · linked event required

Appeals / reconsiderations (remain visible)

  • APL-001 — case CASE-004 under-review
    Reconsideration requested on the QC remediation scope. · remains visible
  • APL-002 — case CASE-008 open
    Reconsideration of the blocked finding requested. · remains visible

Evidence (presence ≠ verification; conflicts remain visible)

  • EVD-001 — disbursement-voucher present verified current
    fund-accountability · case CASE-001
  • EVD-002 — receipt-confirmation missing missing current
    stockpile-logistics · case CASE-002 · Missing evidence blocks a final finding; remains visible.
  • EVD-003 — movement-log present verified current
    stockpile-logistics · case CASE-003
  • EVD-004 — qc-record present verified current
    lab-operations · case CASE-004
  • EVD-005 — routing-record present unverified current
    lab-operations · case CASE-005
  • EVD-006 — follow-up-record missing missing current
    patient-continuity · case CASE-005B · Missing follow-up evidence remains visible.
  • EVD-007 — disclosure-decision-record present verified current
    restricted-patient-locator · case CASE-006
  • EVD-008 — custody-verification present unverified current
    asset-management · case CASE-007
  • EVD-009 — result-source-document present unverified current
    program-performance · case CASE-008
  • EVD-010 — ai-signal-source-link present unverified current
    ai-intelligence · case CASE-009
  • EVD-011 — dependency-status-record missing missing current
    country-rollout · case CASE-010 · Dependency evidence missing; blocks final finding.
  • EVD-012 — access-attempt-record present verified current
    executive-review-packet · case CASE-012
  • EVD-013 — access-decision-record present unverified current
    identity-access-governance · case CASE-011
  • EVD-014 — claim-source present verified current
    data-quality-reconciliation · case CASE-013 · Verified evidence that conflicts with EVD-015; both remain visible.
  • EVD-015 — capability-state-record present verified current
    data-quality-reconciliation · case CASE-013 · Verified evidence conflicting with EVD-014; capability state is 'planned'. Conflicting evidence remains visible.
  • EVD-016 — prior-custody-verification present verified superseded
    asset-management · case CASE-007 · Superseded by later verification; remains historically visible.
  • EVD-017 — exculpatory-context-record present verified current
    lab-operations · case CASE-005 · Exculpatory / conflicting context evidence retained and never suppressed.
  • EVD-018 — legacy-assessment present verified superseded
    fund-accountability · case · Stale legacy risk assessment; requires re-review.

AI risk signals (human review required)

  • value-variance — Fund disbursement/expenditure variance flagged for review. medium
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-001
  • missing-record — Warehouse receipt confirmation missing. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-002
  • balance-divergence — Recorded stock balance diverges from movement history. medium
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-003
  • restricted-result-unrouted — Restricted lab result not routed to clinician. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-005
  • missing-followup — Follow-up record missing for a completed transfer. medium
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-005B
  • restricted-access-concern — Restricted-locator access concern raised. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-006
  • asset-custody-unverified — Asset active but custody unverified. medium
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-007
  • outlier — Program result far above target; an outlier is not a finding. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-008
  • duplicate-pattern — AI-clustered possible-duplicate disbursement pattern; an anomaly is not proof. medium
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-009
  • unsupported-claim — Rollout readiness claim contradicts an incomplete dependency. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-010
  • expired-access-active — Approved access with expired authorization still active. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-011
  • unauthorized-access-attempt — Unauthorized packet-access attempt blocked. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-012
  • conflicting-evidence — Reconciliation conflict with conflicting verified evidence; both remain visible. high
    human review: yes · autonomous action: no · case CASE-013

Immutable audit events (append-only)

Audit events are append-only in this demonstration model; corrections, finding reversals, and reopen events require new linked events; deletion is not an allowed case-management control; source-module audit records remain authoritative. This is not a production cryptographic audit ledger.

  • AUD-001 — case-opened open
    case-owner · fund-accountability · 2025-03-06T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-002 — case-escalated blocked
    independent-reviewer · stockpile-logistics · 2025-06-03T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-003 — case-opened open
    case-owner · stockpile-logistics · 2025-07-03T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-004 — case-closed closed-after-approval
    compliance-reviewer · lab-operations · 2025-05-20T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-005 — case-blocked blocked
    independent-reviewer · lab-operations · 2025-05-15T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-006 — case-opened open
    case-owner · patient-continuity · 2025-05-21T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-007 — case-opened open
    independent-reviewer · restricted-patient-locator · 2025-05-03T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-008 — case-reopened CASE-007-S2 reopen of AUD-008-prior
    independent-reviewer · asset-management · 2025-08-20T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-009 — case-escalated escalated
    independent-reviewer · program-performance · 2025-06-22T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-010 — case-opened open
    investigator · ai-intelligence · 2025-06-02T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-011 — case-escalated escalated
    independent-reviewer · country-rollout · 2025-09-02T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-012 — case-opened open
    compliance-reviewer · executive-review-packet · 2025-07-11T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-013 — case-escalated escalated
    independent-reviewer · identity-access-governance · 2025-08-16T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-014 — case-blocked blocked
    independent-reviewer · data-quality-reconciliation · 2025-07-05T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes
  • AUD-015 — finding-reversed reopened finding reversal of FND-008
    second-reviewer · asset-management · 2025-08-21T09:05:00Z · immutable: yes

Cases by module

  • fund-accountability 1
  • stockpile-logistics 2
  • lab-operations 2
  • patient-continuity 1
  • restricted-patient-locator 1
  • asset-management 1
  • program-performance 1
  • ai-intelligence 1
  • country-rollout 1
  • identity-access-governance 1
  • executive-review-packet 1
  • data-quality-reconciliation 1
  • authorized-review-room 1

Cases by country

  • CN-A 14
  • CN-B 1

Cases by category

  • financial-integrity 1
  • commodity-integrity 2
  • laboratory-quality 2
  • patient-safety-continuity 1
  • privacy-access 1
  • asset-accountability 1
  • program-integrity 1
  • ai-signal-review 1
  • rollout-control 1
  • identity-governance 1
  • review-access-control 2
  • data-quality-integrity 1

Cases by severity / status

  • high 8
  • critical 1
  • medium 6
  • open 8
  • blocked 3
  • closed 1
  • reopened 1
  • escalated 2

AI posture — assistive only, non-autonomous

AI assists with

  • detect risk signals and anomalies
  • cluster related incidents
  • compare cases across authorized modules
  • detect missing or conflicting evidence
  • identify stale cases and overdue actions
  • suggest investigation hypotheses
  • suggest competing explanations
  • map findings to supporting evidence
  • identify unsupported conclusions
  • prioritize cases for review
  • recommend escalation or second review
  • summarize chronology for authorized reviewers
  • detect separation-of-duties conflicts
  • identify potentially ineffective remediation
  • support root-cause analysis

AI must never

  • autonomously open a punitive case
  • autonomously determine fraud, diversion, misconduct, negligence, guilt, or liability
  • autonomously substantiate allegations
  • autonomously approve findings
  • autonomously close or reopen cases
  • autonomously notify law enforcement, regulators, funders, employers, or affected individuals
  • autonomously assign disciplinary action
  • autonomously suppress exculpatory or conflicting evidence
  • autonomously fabricate evidence
  • autonomously alter source records
  • autonomously approve corrective-action effectiveness
  • autonomously authorize case export
  • bypass human review, second review, separation of duties, confidentiality, evidence, expiration, revocation, or audit controls

AI is assistive only. It surfaces risk signals, clusters incidents, compares cases, maps findings to evidence, and prioritizes review for authorized humans, and never opens punitive cases, determines fraud or liability, substantiates allegations, approves findings, closes or reopens cases, notifies external parties, assigns discipline, suppresses evidence, fabricates evidence, alters source records, approves remediation effectiveness, authorizes export, or bypasses controls.

Runtime boundary & module coverage

fund-accountability stockpile-logistics lab-operations patient-continuity restricted-patient-locator asset-management program-performance ai-intelligence country-rollout authorized-review-room executive-review-packet identity-access-governance data-quality-reconciliation